论文部分内容阅读
法律解释的立场是法律解释学的重要理论问题。王彬博士的《法律解释的本体与方法》代表了一种“调和”的立场,主张法律解释应当在本体与方法之间保持适当的张力。该书围绕三个核心论题——法律解释的“认识论困境”、“政治学难题”和“方法论反思”——展开了深入的探讨,推进了法律解释学立场问题的研究。然而,它还是无法独立完成法律解释的“建设性任务”——限制法官的恣意,追问创造性司法的正当性依据。因此,有必要将法律解释与法律论证结合起来,形成两者交替前行(解释一证立—再解释—再证立)的格局。
The legal interpretation of the position is an important theoretical issue of legal hermeneutics. Dr. Wang Bin’s “Ontology and Method of Legal Interpretation” represents a “reconciliation” position, arguing that legal interpretation should maintain proper tension between ontology and methodology. The book explores the three core issues - the “epistemological dilemma” of legal interpretation, the political difficult questions and the “methodological reflections” of legal interpretation, and advances the study on the position of legal hermeneutics . However, it is still a “constructive task” in which legal interpretation can not be done independently. This limits the judge’s arbitrary and questionable justification of creative justice. Therefore, it is necessary to combine the legal interpretation with the legal argumentation to form the pattern of alternating forward (interpretation of one set of evidence - re-explanation - re-verification).