指导小学生作文,究竟是先确定中心、还是先选材,《小学教学研究》1999年第5期和第9期分别发表李正存老师《先确定中心还是先选材》和张运群老师《还是应该“中心先行”》两篇文章,对此展开了针锋相对的争鸣和探讨。张老师的文章(以下简称“张文”)是主张“主题(即中心)先行”的,事实上这种观点在教学中颇有代表性,并不自觉地使作文指导形成了一种“主题先行”的误区。因此,笔者不惴浅陋,也想谈谈自己的看法,兼与张老师商榷。一、主题先行有悖于写作规律 Guide primary school composition, whether it is to determine the center first, or the first choice, “Primary Teaching Research” 1999 fifth and ninth were issued by Li Zhengcun teacher “first to determine the center or the first selection of materials” and Zhang Yunqun teacher “or should” center first “ ”Two articles, launched a tit-for-tat argument and discussion. Zhang's article (hereinafter referred to as “Zhang Wen”) advocates that “the subject (ie, the center) should be advanced”. In fact, this viewpoint is quite representative in teaching and does not consciously make writing guidance form a “theme First ”misunderstanding. Therefore, I am not shallow, I also want to talk about my own views, and discuss with Professor Zhang. First, the theme is contrary to the law of writing