针对邓子基教授的《建立稳固、平衡、强大的国家财政与构建公共财政的基本框架》(发表于《财贸经济》2002年第1期,以下简称《框架》)一文,李茂生教授在《财贸经济》2002年第3期发表了文章《科学认识财政基本问题,逐步建立现代公共财政——与邓子基教授商榷》(以下简称《商榷》)。在《商榷》一文中,李教授以“剩 In response to Professor Deng Ziji “to establish a stable, balanced and powerful national finance and the construction of public finance, the basic framework” (published in “Finance and Trade Economy” No. 1, 2002, hereinafter referred to as the “framework”), Professor Li Maosheng in the “ ”2002 the third issue of an article“ scientific understanding of the basic financial issues, and gradually establish a modern public finance - Discussion with Professor Deng Ziji ”(hereinafter referred to as“ deliberation ”). In the “discussion” article, Professor Lee to "left