论文部分内容阅读
谢宗玉先生写过不少电影评论,但所评电影大多未曾在中国大陆公演过,因此,其评论究竟是否得当,实在让人难以言说。然而,既是评论,终究要表达评论者的某些观点,体现其价值取向,那么对这些观念有所质疑,也该是顺理成章的。比如,他在2011年第二期《随笔》发表了《〈鬼子来了〉:战争是文明的崩盘》。笔者尽管无缘观看《鬼子来了》这部电影,但对谢先生在影评中所宣扬的某些观点却不能不说上几句。
Mr. Xie Zongyu has written many movie commentary, but most of the movies he has not shown in Mainland China have performed. Therefore, it is hard to say whether his comment is proper or not. However, as comments, after all, to express some viewpoints of commentators and reflect their value orientation, it is logical that these concepts should be questioned. For example, he published “Evil Devil” in the second issue of 2011: War is the Crash in Civilization. Despite the fact that the author missed the movie “The Devil came,” I can not but say a few words about some of the points Mr. Xie preached during the film criticism.