《建筑学报》1980年第6期发表了唐璞、江道元同志的“住宅建筑新体系的初探”(以下简称“初探”)一文,提出了住宅建筑中采用工业化蜂窝元件组合体的设想。本文拟就“初探”中的设想及观点提出一些不同的看法,与唐,江两位同志商榷。 一、关于创新的目的性问题 “初探”开始就承认“住宅建筑以矩形或方形平面及其空间为主的建筑体系的形成由来 In the sixth issue of the Journal of Architecture, published in the 6th issue of Tang dynasty and Comrade Jiang Daoyuan’s “A Preliminary Study of the New System of Residential Buildings” (hereinafter referred to as “Exploration”), the idea of ​​using industrial honeycomb components in residential buildings was proposed. This article proposes to put forward some different views on the tentative ideas and viewpoints of the “exploration” and to discuss with the two comrades Tang and Jiang. First, the purpose of innovation on the “problem” began to admit the "domestic building with rectangular or square plane and its space-based building system