编辑同志: 本刊1979年第1期发表的“烯烃和环烯烃的亲电加成反应机理”一文,在解释碳正离子的稳定性大小时,认为用杂化轨道中s和p成分的多少及其能量的大小来比较,比用超共轭效应解释更能说明问题。我认为这种解释方法值得商榷。一般认为碳正离子的稳定性大小取决于所带电荷 Editorial comrades: The first issue of 1979 issue of “olefin and cycloolefin olefin electrophilic reaction mechanism” article, in explaining the stability of carbon positive ion size, that the use of hybrid orbital s and p component number And the size of its energy to compare, explain the problem better than the superconjugation effect. I think this method of interpretation is questionable. It is generally believed that the stability of carbon positive ions depends on the charge