本文试图指出庄天明先生《执笔的流变——中国历代执笔图像汇考》一书中,对中国古代图文资料中所示执笔法的几处误读。主要观点包括:握管法、二指单钩法、三指双钩法绝非古代执笔的常法,古代图像中的很多例子由于作者造型能力的欠缺无法真实反映当时的一般执笔习惯;古人执笔为求其便,在不同的情境下会选取不同的执笔方式,决不可执一而论;拨镫法是对于笔势的比附,不能和古代图像当中的拨灯图像等量齐观;清人文献中曲解古代执笔法的例子所在多有,在引用之前一定要加以仔细甄别等等。 This article attempts to point out several mistakes made by Mr. Zhuang Tianming in his book “The Evolution of Writing - The Collection of Essays in Chinese Era”. The main points of view include: grip method, two fingers single hook method, three fingers double hook method is by no means the ancient practice of writing, many examples in the ancient images due to the lack of the ability of the author can not truly reflect the general writing habits; Seek their own convenience, in different situations will choose a different way to write, must not be imposible; dial 镫 law is attached to the gestures can not be the same as the ancient images of the dial light; Qi literature; There are many examples of the law, which must be carefully screened before being quoted.