《农业气象》1985年第1期发表了徐其兴同志的“橡胶树辐射型低温霜害是冷害还是冻害问题的分析”一文(下面简称“徐文”),提出了橡胶树在零下霜冻发生的急性霜害是冷害而不是冻害的论点,并对我们在本刊1983年第4期提出的“橡胶树既有寒害,也有冻害”的观点,作了根本的否定。对于徐文的论点、概念和分析方法,我们提出不同的看法,就下面三个问题进行商 “Agricultural Meteorology” in 1985 the first issue of Comrade Xu Qixing “rubber tree radiation cold frost injury is the problem of cold damage or frost” article (hereinafter referred to as “Xu Wen”), proposed that the rubber tree in the subzero frost acute frost damage is cold damage Not the argument of frost damage, and made a fundamental denial of the view that “the rubber tree has both cold and dampness and cold frost damage” put forward in the 4th issue of this journal in 1983. For Xu’s arguments, concepts and analytical methods, we put forward different views on the following three questions